[MV Review] Humanoids

Hello! So sorry for the holiday hiatus. Welcome back to Cynical Kpop which will hopefully have a new feel after leaving the restrictions of a classroom. Today we look at the  latest TVXQ single, “Humanoids”.

(Original)

(Subtitles)

This massively popular Kpop Group TVXQ had their Korean comeback late 2012 and have a new cynical song. Usually, they stick to love songs and adolescent angst about time and stress. However, this song features some interesting and cynical lyrics. Check out the MV’s above (the second having English subtitles). The song has messages about seizing the day and building the future, but there are cynical undertones beneath commenting on the dangers of the status quo.

They have already perfected it, the scenario that hides everything.

They make a clear distinction of a young generation in the song, so this distinct opposing group could easily be interpreted as the older generations. Miss A venerated their parents, but TVXQ seems to be making a rebellious comment about them; albeit they do it in a vague manner. One line has a clear message of action, though:

Break apart this twisted space

I’m not sure about the connotation in the original Korean,. but the translator felt twisted fit–maligned, crooked, harmful, and dangerous.
It’s the future, we’re humanoids on top of a fragment
It’s overflowing with the utopia that you and I have created
It’s the future, we are humanoids to change the future

Is TVXQ talking about the fragmentation of urban life and living and how modern Korean society builds barriers between people of different statuses and identities? Is this a steampunk video and are they actually talking about an alternate past where humans meet machines and are a fragment of both forced together? How are we breaking apart this twisted, fragmented world and rebuilding it? Well, I think I’m looking too far into it as do others who bring up these theories because the video matches none of this. For a Kpop song though, you usually do not have the freedom to speculate so wildly and bring so many ideas.

A place where masks won’t work, where the wrong can be pointed out
Where I can breathe when I run out of breath
Yeah, let’s choose that kind of world

We come back to some solid Kpop themes when songs try to preach a message–this one paints a paradoxical view of Korea, the 빨리빨리 ( balli balli, literally quick quick but more like a encouraging statement faster, faster) nature moving quickly and always growing versus the conservative efforts of keeping opinions and feelings to yourself instead of trying to adapt and change. The vagueness remains in their call and response of, “Are we awakened? Does the answer change?” This appears to lack any meaning and just promotes a mysterious feeling.. Then again these are all a translation and my Korean is not good enough to evaluate it.  I thought for a Korean pop song this had a different and intriguing set of lyrics. The imagery provides little other than the loveliness of TVXQ and some futuristic dystopia-meets Steampunk (how is that even possible?), but perhaps next time we will get some cynical visuals too.

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “[MV Review] Humanoids

  1. That’s some interesting analysis there.
    Having said that, it seems ironic that SM releases this kind of lyrics in a sense, because SM Entertainment is this huge enterprise where idols are treated more like workers, less like artists [humanoids?]. They make them keep up with crazy schedules, lack of sleep, plastic surgeries etc. in order to make more money. There are a couple of articles out there on ‘the dark side of SM entertainment’, check them out. After I read them, I would say ‘balli balli’ is a perfect phrase to describe SM, although not so many Kpop fans realise that. On that note, I still listen to SM artists lol. Nice article.

    • That is a great point; it is ironic considering the structure of the K pop industry, largely led by SM entertainment. In a way K-pop being cynical is being hypocritical, and that is why it is so interesting.

      University of California, Berkeley Undergraduate | Asian Studies Major Class of 2015

Leave a Cynical Response

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s